Wednesday, April 2, 2014
"Too Big to Know: Rethinking Knowledge Now That The Facts Aren't The Facts, Experts are Everywhere, and the Smartest Person in the Room Is the Room."
David Weinberger's docent title hits the nail on the head.
The author points out the incorrect emphasis that writers and experts in a given field emphasize. The British Petroleum Oil Spill, for example, became the main topic of discussion when "the real topic is the limits of expert knowledge in tackling complex problems" (vii); within a discussion, the surface issue, or the result of the problem, takes precedence when the knowledge processes leading to the issue are the actual cause of the problem. And, in questioning the knowledge, one must question the foundation on which said facts are built.
Weinberger discusses the history of facts, and in doing so, points out that the basis of knowledge comes from facts as opposed to "logical deduction[s] from grand principles" (26). Facts are the "bricks" of the knowledge "house" that construct our paradigms of values, truth, and reality. This way, knowledge built and supported by solid facts cannot be widely discredited or challenged. And, because of the fact that a single person cannot possess the knowledge of humanity, using second sources and follow the "footnotes" of other sources (21).
His approach to dissecting the basis of knowledge and the human capacity for fully understanding shows that, for the most part, people are asking the wrong questions when it comes to information, data, and knowledge as a whole.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment